Episode Transcript
[00:00:04] Hi, everybody. Welcome along to another episode of the Dispatchers podcast. My name is Brendan Malone. It is great to be back with you again. And today I want to talk about the Wes Huff scandal.
[00:00:14] And I have been deliberately silent on this issue, despite the fact that it's been all over social media and a lot of people have been commenting on it. And there's been two reasons why I've been silent, because number one is I don't actually think we need to comment on every single thing that happens in the public square. And I'm really trying to work hard on not just being one of those reactive guys who's on social media, just constantly reacting. And there's no proper forethought and no prudence and certainly no Christian forethought about what I'm saying. You know, just rushing to pass a comment and rushing to judgment because everyone else is, is not a good thing. That's not Christian virtue. So that's number one reason. And number two is because the facts were not actually clear. Lots of people passing comment on this, but it wasn't entirely clear exactly what had gone on here.
[00:01:09] The scandal in a nutshell. I don't want to relitigate all of it because I'm pretty sure that most of you who are listening to this episode are aware of the fact that Protestant apologist Wes Huff is now in some very serious trouble because of his conduct and the conduct related to plagiarism, to stealing other people's material and attributing it to yourself by not actually giving them proper credit. And this is not just a matter of some footnotes.
[00:01:36] This is like the. Initially, what happened was. And this is why for me, at the very beginning, I was kind of suspicious about what was actually going on. But I didn't want to be uncharitable, and I didn't want to believe or cast aspersions on anyone unfairly. So I felt it was prudent to wait. What I mean by that is that just over a week ago, a YouTube personality who's outside of the Christian church publicly made the claims in a video that West Huff had plagiarised major parts of a paper, an academic paper that he had submitted.
[00:02:12] And it's part. It was part of. I believe it was part of his master's thesis, if I understand the timeline correctly.
[00:02:19] And then Wes Huff came back with a video response of his own. And in that video response, what he said, my spidey senses were tingling because it just didn't quite make sense.
[00:02:31] So what he said in the video was not concordant with where he actually landed. So in the video, he did two things.
[00:02:39] One, he admitted that something had happened. And he said this by saying, you know, my scholarly work 10 years ago was not actually up to standard and I wouldn't like the me of 10 years ago either. So that's him admitting that something has gone on.
[00:02:54] But then he concluded the video by effectively suggesting that this was a nothing burger, that he had simply just created a draft paper and mistakes had been made in the draft paper and he was simply using the platform, this educational platform, as a type of Dropbox, and this wasn't the final paper. Etc, Etc.
[00:03:15] Now, if this really was a nothing burger, it struck me as strange that, you know, you'd be making a video of this nature, first of all. But I mean, it's understandable why in the communications area people would want to perhaps get out ahead of, you know, lies that are being told and correct the record.
[00:03:32] But more importantly, I don't understand why you would say that there was a problem 10 years ago and then try and say that there wasn't a problem, like conclude the video by saying it was a nothing burger. Because if it's a nothing burger, then it's a nothing burger. But you don't also say, you know, I wouldn't like the me of 10 years ago. And my scholarly work of 10 years ago wasn't up to snuff.
[00:03:52] It just. It didn't quite sit well with me. But again, I didn't want to cast aspersions and I didn't want to like believing and saying things about someone that you just have no reason to believe or no substantive reason to believe.
[00:04:05] That is not a good act of Christian charity at all. It's a violation of Christian charity.
[00:04:12] So over the ensuing days, though, more and more information started coming to light and it became apparent within a matter of days and as the week has now worn on, that it wasn't simply one paper, it was multiple papers.
[00:04:29] It also came to light that, and this hasn't been fully finally confirmed by Weiss himself, but based on the apology that he has published today, New Zealand time, he has given a very lengthy admission of his guilt. It does seems that it does seem sorry that this is reasonable, but basically several days ago, it began publicly circulating that Wes Huff, who was working through his PhD dissertation, that basically his oversight committee for that, had resigned because of his plagiarism. There was a problem here and he hadn't been fully truthful with people about that fact.
[00:05:10] And so this means that not Only was this serious, not only was this ongoing, but it was also currently still happening. But it wasn't just academic work. It was also plagiarism that was found in sermons he had given and also, like public messages he delivered and also in videos that he had created and uploaded to YouTube. And there's one video in particular where the level of, of content in that video that is lifted directly word for word from another person's written work with zero attribution to that person.
[00:05:47] Like, it's. Yeah, it's not just the thing that happens where basically, you know, there's no new ideas under the sun. And often, you know, ideas are very common, they're very popular. And particularly in, in like, if you're thinking about podcasting or speaking spaces, people will say things and they won't necessarily know where they've picked it up from or what the original source was. It wasn't one of those kind of moments.
[00:06:09] It was quite a bit more than that. So what had gone on here was serious.
[00:06:15] It was, in fact, at times it was quite brazen what was happening. And it was ongoing. And so today, finally, what's happened is Wes Huff has published on his social media channels a relatively lengthy public admission of guilt and apology.
[00:06:33] And, and I would have to say, looking purely at what's written in that apology and his admission of guilt, this public act of contrition, it's a pretty well worded public act of contrition. We'll get to that point, though, more we'll get to a bit more on that point in just a second because I think we still need to be cautious here. But it is, on face value, it is a very well worded public apology and it's a full and frank admission that Wes has been engaging in serious levels of dishonesty and this has been ongoing.
[00:07:11] Now, why I wanted to make this video today, though, was because, like, I'm extremely aware of the fact that again, in moments like this, the temptation is that every man and his dog thinks, ah, I should share my opinions with the world, because my opinions with the world are the most important thing. And, you know, people need to hear from me. The truth is, they don't need to hear from us. Actually, even someone like me, I have a ministry that involves public speaking and obviously I have this podcast and it's all part of what I do. But you don't need to really hear that much from me.
[00:07:45] What you need to hear from is you need to hear from Jesus.
[00:07:48] I say that, I don't say that. Flippantly I'm not being tried about that. All of us, we need more of that and less of all of the reactions to things.
[00:07:57] So, again, I was reticent about whether or not I would comment, but the reason I wanted to comment was because I felt like there was something burning away in me that I had not seen anybody else say.
[00:08:15] And it's not really about Wes, actually. It's about the, it's about any situation like this. But it's, it's.
[00:08:23] How should we say? It's, it's effectively, it is a.
[00:08:29] The West Huff situation. And the scandal is actually a warning to all of us, and it's a reminder to all of us. Maybe that's a better way of putting it, a reminder to all of us about what is really important. And I think we've got some misplaced priorities that have actually aided and created and fanned the flames of this very scandal.
[00:08:50] And I think it's important for us to think about where our priorities as Christians might be misplaced and how possibly recovering what should be our priorities is actually going to help hedge and be a safeguard against this sort of scandal from happening. You can't stop this stuff from happening. The human heart is a messy and complicated thing, and the line between good and evil runs through it.
[00:09:18] And every human being is fallible and is prone to sinning. And it's just the reality of it. And the human condition is such that, you know, it can be very tempting to fall into all sorts of sins. Every one of us has sins that we grapple with.
[00:09:32] And so I thought I would make this video, though, for a couple of reasons. Number one is I'm thinking here, particularly of my Protestant brothers and sisters who might be tuned in, and also maybe anyone else, like Catholics and others who maybe haven't seen serious scandal from Christian leaders up close and personal like this. Like this is a pretty serious scandal and for some people. And that, of course, is the greatest evil in all of this, really, or one of the greatest evils. And one of the great tragedies is the serious scandal that this creates for Christ and for the potential, the very real potential of the loss of souls from the kingdom, those souls who are so scandalized by this that they turn their back on Christ. And that's a great, horrible, horrific tragedy that comes out of the back of this kind of thing. It's true anytime any Christian leader or person of profile engages in very serious public sin.
[00:10:31] And the reason why, I thought, first of all, so there's sort of two parts to this the first part is me sort of trying to offer some what I think are hopefully helpful insights. And I say this as someone who has seen up close and personal over the. What's more than 20 years now, almost 30 years really, since the sexual abuse crisis, which by the way, is a crisis across all denominations. But very publicly, the Catholic Church has received, I think it's fair to say that is starting to change now. But it's fair to say has received the majority of the public attention and scrutiny for these kind of behaviors. It's across all denominations. The data indicates it is consistent across all denominations.
[00:11:13] So it's. The problem is, I think this context does matter. By the way, I don't want to downplay the awful atrocities and the victimization of victims of sexual abuse from any particular stripe or flavor of clergy, whether they be Protestant or Catholic. But I think it is important to remember that in actual fact, the vast majority of Christian ministers, be they Protestant or Catholic, they are not engaged in sexual abuse.
[00:11:40] Thankfully, it is still a, in the scheme of things, it is a minority of people who engage in these awful acts of abuse and they rightly deserve and should be strongly and soundly called out in the most unflinching terms. But thankfully the, this is, it's still not a majority issue. So I think that's important to, to make clear.
[00:12:02] You probably wouldn't realize that if you just listen solely to the public focus on this often, particularly from the media, it feels like, especially when you're getting constant attention, being dedicated to this. And again, I think it's right if someone has abused someone else that they should be absolutely. I mean that sin should be called out and the victims should be given afforded proper justice. It's just, that is just fundamental Christianity 101. Right. So we shouldn't try and shy away from any of this. But when you, you know, you get this media attention and it seems so high profile, it can be very easy to forget that in actual fact it is not the majority of clergy. It is a minority.
[00:12:42] And also it can be very easy to lose sight of the fact that in actual fact other institutions that have got nothing to do with Christianity or religion have the same issues. And in fact some of them are far worse in their offending levels. And so I think those caveats are important to keep in mind. But having seen the clergy sexual abuse crisis from the Catholic side of the fence and myself personally having witnessed on a couple of occasions up close and personal, the impact of that in people's lives, whether that's victims or whether that's people I knew and trusted who actually were perpetrators. I have been on a journey, if you like, over these past couple of decades of having to sort of grapple with this myself. And I think there are some important learnings and lessons that perhaps my Protestant brothers and sisters could find helpful in a situation like this. So I want to share a couple of those points, and then I want to get to my main point towards the end, which, again, is really the reason for. The big reason for making this episode is I just didn't want to be part of a pylon. And. And I didn't also just want to join in some sort of absurd and scandalous gossip circle where all we're doing is just gossiping about Wes Huff and his very public failings. That's not Christian either.
[00:13:56] Before I get into that, though, I will just share my personal thoughts, and only very briefly. But for me personally, I did have concerns about Wes Huff well before any of this became apparent. And I just. I think.
[00:14:14] I don't think unreasonably. I just sat on those concerns because I didn't really know what to make of them. And I didn't. Yeah, in my mind, they didn't rise to the level of, you know, I must tell other people about this. And also, I'm not directly accountable for Wes half. And it's not really like I have the ability to, I guess, to. To make public statements that will make a meaningful impact, you know, for individual accountability for someone like Wes Huff, who found himself on this meteoric rise to fame.
[00:14:45] In fact, this goes all the way back to really the moment where he hit the big time. And that was when he appeared on the Joe Rogan podcast.
[00:14:53] And it was. Yeah, his cachet, it just. It skyrocketed, and he became very quickly a celebrity of epic proportions.
[00:15:04] But in that Joe Rogan appearance, that was a really big moment. In that Joe Rogan appearance, he made a statement about the scroll of Isaiah that is found in the Dead Sea Scrolls.
[00:15:17] We don't need to relitigate all of it. You can Google it and see what the issue was if you want to. But he made the claim that the Isaiah, the text of Isaiah that we have in our Bibles is word for word identical to what's found in that Dead Sea Scrolls version. It's not.
[00:15:33] That's not a problem, by the way.
[00:15:36] Christianity has been grappling with these kind of realities from the very beginning.
[00:15:40] And so the idea of differences in manuscripts is. It's just not an issue. It's only a problem if you're going to wrongly assume that the Bible effectively fell out of the year intact, fully intact.
[00:15:53] If you detach the Christian Scriptures from the Church who was given authority to proclaim those scriptures, and the authority which God used to reveal those scriptures to the world, then you know, you're probably going to struggle with this.
[00:16:11] But I'm in a denomination, Catholicism, where that's just not an issue.
[00:16:18] It really isn't an issue.
[00:16:20] But the point was that Wes said something there that was just not accurate at all.
[00:16:27] Now, at the time, in response, others came to his defence and I think, I can't remember exactly how he responded or whether he did respond to that actually, gosh, it's been. It's only a couple of years ago, but it feels like it was years and years ago, doesn't it? But others I saw come into his defence saying, oh, he probably just misspoke.
[00:16:46] And I don't think that's an unreasonable claim under ordinary circumstances to make. But in this context, I'm like, that didn't really quite convince me because of the scholarly credentials that Wes Huff was claiming that he had and particularly the specialty that he was claiming to have.
[00:17:06] And it just, it never quite sat right with me. But as I said, maybe he did just misspeak.
[00:17:13] Looking back now, though, and with this public admission and what we know, I wonder if in actual fact it was one of those situations where Wes just didn't actually know enough.
[00:17:24] He didn't really understand the text and the differences because possibly he had just heard others talking about it and he had just picked up what they'd said and run with it, as opposed to having deeply understood and studied this himself.
[00:17:39] So there are a couple of things like that I look back on now and I think, I wonder if that was the case, if basically this was the fruit of plagiarism manifesting itself. Because if you're plagiarizing, there's a really high chance that you're not studying, you're just lifting content from other people. And if you're plagiarizing, there's a really high chance that you're not necessarily going back to the sources to check this or understanding it fully yourself.
[00:18:06] And another one of those red flags actually happened to me. There were a couple of them when he was making statements against the Catholic Church.
[00:18:14] And I'm not averse, I'm not shocked by people who are anti Catholic or who make anti Catholic statements.
[00:18:24] Again, that's the reality of the human condition.
[00:18:27] People are going to hold views, they're going to have their own belief. Some of them are deeply ingrained.
[00:18:33] There's a lot of tribalism at times around these things. And so I'm not surprised. And people say, well, I'm in this tribe and that's not my tribe. And so they just say anti Catholic things because they're anti that tribe. Right. And so I'm not shocked by that component of it. But what was for me a red flag was on more than one occasion, Wes Huff said things that were demonstrably untrue, like they were historically not correct.
[00:19:02] And like one thing, and remember one thing. Sorry. In particular that I remember was a statement he made about the documents that were produced by the Council of Trent, the Catholic Council of Trent.
[00:19:17] And he made a statement about one section of the documents of the Council of Trent that was actually demonstrably false. The document didn't say what he was claiming that it said. And I remember thinking to myself at the time, I don't think he's lying. That would be a very uncharitable interpretation to put on this, that West Huff is just blatantly telling lies and you know, like the tribalistic thing where you just, you lie because. And you knowingly do that. That didn't seem like a fair assumption.
[00:19:50] But what I did think at the time was I thought, has he actually read the documents or does he actually understand the documents and why it was and these and other eras of this nature. Like I said, it wasn't the anti Catholicism, it was the nature of the error. It was the kind of error that someone would make who actually wasn't a scholar, who wasn't studying things, who was or maybe was straying well outside their actual areas of expertise.
[00:20:22] And so that, that was the issue for me. And so there was these little red flags that kept popping up.
[00:20:29] And this one in particular I look back on now and again, I wonder if in actual fact this is another fruit of plagiarism. You've seen something said somewhere else by a different person and, and you've just repeated it.
[00:20:45] And the implication is that you've studied the documents, then maybe you haven't even looked at the documents. You've just repeated something that is a factual error, that is a lie, that is incorrect, but you didn't realize that what you were saying was incorrect.
[00:21:00] So it is possible, again, that why that moment happened was because in actual fact, Wes was not as well schooled as he was leading people to believe, because a lot of his work was just being lifted wholesale from others in order to get letters that would give credentials, that would give you public acclaim and pedigree and ability to be able to say, well, you should listen to me because I am an X, Y and Z. I am a master's, I am a doctor of whatever. And so there were lots of little moments like that. And others I saw calling him out on this, by the way too, and clearly they were noticing it as well, that there were just these red flags that Wes was just saying things that were what you would call low brow anti Catholicism. And what I mean by that is just sort of urban myths or urban legends or stuff that people say it's tribalistic because they don't understand the church, they don't understand church history, they haven't really properly engaged with the sources.
[00:21:59] And so, and by the way, that happens across the board. You can have low brow attacks on people that happens anywhere, not just within Christianity and not just across the religious divide, but also in politics and all sorts of areas. You know, so there were these red flags. And so I look back now on a lot of those red flags and I, I just can't help but wonder if they were actually the fruit of so much plagiarism and, and an appearance of scholarly credential that wasn't really there.
[00:22:31] So, yeah, that's my take, for whatever it's worth. But let me share a couple of things that I think are worthy of taking note of, particularly again for my Protestant brothers and sisters, or maybe those of any ilk who this is maybe their first encounter with a, you know, high profile Christian or a Christian leader who has engaged in serious scandal. The first thing I would say is don't downplay the seriousness, the gravity of what has actually happened here.
[00:22:58] And that has been going on all week. And I've seen lots of people, and even today, now that this public apology and this public admission of guilt has been issued, I'm seeing people in the comments section beneath that. And this is, as I said, it's been happening all week. People are downplaying the gravity of what has gone on here and people saying, oh, it's not a big deal, people saying this is just people who are jealous of you.
[00:23:22] The truth is you can have two things that are true at the same time and I've got no problem at all. It's clear to me, having engaged with the content that is being put out there where people are actually critiquing Wes Huff and calling out his behavior, what's. That's been going on for years now that there are People who are critiquing him with a genuine concern for the gravity of what's gone on here. And then there are others who, who are more than happy to use this as a weapon because it serves their ideological aims. They don't like Wes Huff for whatever reason, or they are staunchly like the sort of the, the last holdouts of the militant new Atheism. And they don't like the fact that, you know, there is a robust and popularly acclaimed defense of Christian belief. And so this serves their purpose.
[00:24:19] But two things can be true at the same time. So people can have bad motives, but they can also be highlighting something that is true and that is very real and, you know, and serious. So it is a tragedy to see people, even Christians in particular, downplaying the gravity of this and just saying that persistent serial dishonesty is okay. I've even seen people suggesting that it's okay because it's in the cause of promoting the message of Christianity.
[00:24:47] That's just not true. Christianity rejects utilitarianism. The idea that the end justifies the means that it's okay to do whatever you want as long as your outcome is good. Christianity says no, you must act in a way that is moral, too. So I would say to people, don't downplay the seriousness of what happened. And I would say also avoid any temptation whatsoever to attack and to malign the people who have raised these allegations, because the truth is that's just prolonging the scandal. It is prolonging and making worse the suffering and the potential future harm that will flow on as a result of this. It's just far better to do what King David did when he was confronted by the prophet Nathan and he straight away admits his guilt of his very serious wrongdoing that he's engaged in. And then he engages in a period of public penitence and repentance for what he's done.
[00:25:48] And so you know that that's the way it. And, and that is the way to address these things.
[00:25:55] It's painful, it's horrible, and it's humiliating and everything else, but that's the way. So don't downplay the seriousness. I would say we saw that happen with the Catholic sexual abuse crisis. And it's not a good thing. It's just, it actually didn't help. It prolonged problems. If people had actually been more willing to just tackle it head on when this first the modern crisis began to manifest itself in the very start of the 2000s, I don't think we'd be in the Same place that we're in right now.
[00:26:28] The other thing I'd say is this. The apology is not the end of this. So today's public apology and public admission of serious wrongdoing, his admission of guilt by Wes half. This is only just the beginning.
[00:26:43] And I think that's really important to keep in mind because again, I'm already seeing people online commenting either implicitly or even explicitly suggesting that this is the end of the matter. Right, that's it. He's publicly apologised, he's admitted what he's done here.
[00:26:58] So therefore, let's just get on with it back to Public Ministry west half. And we'll just carry on from here effectively as if nothing has happened. But that's not the way forward. The apology is not the end, it's only just the beginning.
[00:27:12] This has been a brazen pattern of behavior at times, like really brazen.
[00:27:17] And that should cause us to stop and say, hold on a minute. The brazen nature of what has gone on here might speak to some pretty serious character deficiencies or even psychological deficiencies. I'm not passing these judgments, I'm just saying these are. This is what prudence looks like when you think prudently about a matter.
[00:27:38] The brazen nature of this really does require of us a more considered and careful response.
[00:27:49] And to be discerning people.
[00:27:53] The other thing is that the long standing and ongoing nature of this, it's not just something that happened in the past, it's still an ongoing issue. And it's been happening, it seems, right throughout the entirety of his scholarly and throughout his public career.
[00:28:13] So there's something serious here.
[00:28:16] And serious things do require a more serious reaction.
[00:28:21] It's not simply someone who forgot to put footnotes on a paper and they did that 10 years ago. It's not that. That's not what this is.
[00:28:31] It's far more serious and far more ongoing. And as I said, it's been very brazen at times. And that in and of itself should cause us to stop and say, okay, this definitely requires an appropriate level of prudence and caution in response.
[00:28:46] There's also the fact that it's only just a week ago, or approximately a week ago, in which Wes half published that video.
[00:28:53] And if you've seen Mike Winger's response to that video, Mike Winger was very clear that Wes was being dishonest in that video, that he was not admitting to the full scale of this and that he was not telling the full truth about what had gone on. And he released that public video approximately One week ago.
[00:29:13] So that question of honesty and reliability, that's still very much present. It's. It's there. It's. I mean, I hate. It's just horrible to even have to talk about this stuff. He's not even as I'm talking about this, I'm just thinking it's just such a trauma that's been inflicted on the body of Christ and it's just horrible. But, yeah, we need to be prudent about this. And so, as I said, it was a week ago and a video came out, and the video, it wasn't honest.
[00:29:39] And it was also an attempt to try and quash and avoid being accountable. Now maybe you can say Wes was panicking. He was in a desperate state of panic. And we're all human beings, and if we get caught doing wrong in a desperate state of panic, we, you know, we can do things like this. I totally get that. But that. That again, speaks to, again, some deeper issues with the interior life, with the spiritual life, with exactly whether or not you are fully living the life you purport publicly to be living. So all of that is serious. Right? And it requires a more measured response.
[00:30:15] The. The only. Speaking of measured, the only standard by which we can have certainty about two things, about one, the sincerity of this public apology and this public admission of guilt. Because it is, when you look at that public admission, it's a very well written statement, but we still need to be prudent.
[00:30:35] And the only. No, the only standard by which we can know whether or not we're. Is actually being sincere in this and whether or not. So whether he really means this and whether there has been a genuine moment of actual repentance. It's not in the words. It is in the actions that come next.
[00:30:56] It's in the actions. And that was essential. That was a lesson that I think we really did fail to learn on the Catholic side of the fence through this sexual abuse crisis that came to light in the early 2000s, was we really should have, I think, been more prudent in places.
[00:31:16] And I think we also should have been in no rush to vindicate or bring back into public life people who clearly had issues or there were credible allegations.
[00:31:28] So in this case, I don't think there should be a rush to bring Wes back into public ministry.
[00:31:34] And I say that because I think that's actually good primarily for Wes's soul.
[00:31:41] It would be no good to rush a man back into public ministry if there are serious deficiencies in his own character and his own spiritual life.
[00:31:53] That have only just been papered over.
[00:31:56] That's. That's not going to help anybody, and certainly not Wes.
[00:32:01] In fact, I think about this often and some of the greatest work that God does in people's lives.
[00:32:09] See, see what I think. What's this? And this really gets to the main point I want to make today is that we have fallen into a very seductive lie, I think.
[00:32:20] And the seductive lie that we've fallen into is that God does his most powerful work in public and with big, grandiose, flashy displays.
[00:32:31] And in particular in this case. So the more profile you have, the more of an audience you have, the more followers you have. That somehow is proof or testament of a more important and powerful work of God happening in the world.
[00:32:50] And that in no small way has helped to contribute, I think, to this problem.
[00:32:56] And that's why I said I think this is a wake up call.
[00:32:59] It's a wake up call when it comes to Christian influencer culture. And also what I think could rightly be described at times as the apologetics industry. I think some people call it big apologetics.
[00:33:14] Yeah, this sort of, this idea that having high profile people who have this really snappy and very clever rhetoric, particularly on a big stage or in front of a camera or an audience, that's the most important work or that's really where God is doing some of his most effective work.
[00:33:39] And what happens is we get lulled into thinking that's what we should all be like and we're looking for the big moments. And by the way, it's not an unreasonable question for people to ask in a Western culture that is collapsing.
[00:33:53] It's. It's not unfair for people to say. And I regularly encounter this in my public speaking work. A lot of people, I'm regularly talking about this topic to audiences in public because people want to know, how can we be effective in our present age? And that is a good question to ask anyone who cares about Christ and who cares about transmitting and sharing the beautiful message, the goodness, truth and beauty of the Christian tradition to others.
[00:34:23] And seeing people realize this for themselves and experience conversion, that's a good and important thing that's at the heart of the Christian mission. So people should want to know how to do that. Well, and that's a good question to ask.
[00:34:39] So a lot of people ask this question or pose this question. They want to know, but there's a trap. And the trap is thinking I've got to have a ministry.
[00:34:50] Like, what I mean by that is a public profile or a public Ministry. But as I consistently tell audiences, and this is really the rub of what I want to say today, the most important vocation that you can engage in, the most important work that you can engage in and you can do, certainly for me, in my context, it's not public speaking and it's not doing podcasts like this.
[00:35:13] They are important and they can be very important moments and they have their place. I'm not saying that, you know, I'm downplaying any of this. It's all irrelevant. No, that's not what I'm saying.
[00:35:23] But what I'm saying is that we've lost sight of the fact that the most important thing is not the high profile stuff. It's like I say to audiences, my most important work is not here speaking to you today.
[00:35:36] My most important work happens in private when none of you are around.
[00:35:41] The most important thing we need to recover, and I think the Wes Huff scandal is a powerful reminder of this, is that we need to recover the hidden life.
[00:35:57] What do I mean by that? Well, a few years ago, Terrence Mullock, phenomenal filmmaker, made a movie called A Hidden Life, and it is about, based on parts of the life, the true story of Franz Jagerstadter, who was a Catholic farmer in Austria when the Nazis were in power and they tried to forcibly conscript him into the army to fight and kill for them. And he said, I'd be betraying Christ if I did that, so I will not do that. People around him pressured him in his village, even his own church said, come on, mate, you don't have to really mean it. You don't really, you know, say the oath to Hitler and mean it. Just sort of cross your fingers, do it anyway, think of your family, etc. Etc. And he said, no, if I did that, I'd be betraying Christ. I can't do this. He tried for many months to actually go in as a medic. So I won't kill for this regime, but I will save lives. They. They wouldn't let him do that. And so eventually the moment of truth comes and he refuses. And so he is imprisoned and he is eventually taken outside one day and shot and executed.
[00:36:55] And there's a beautiful witness to profound faith here. Something very important happened in that moment.
[00:37:03] It's a very beautiful, well crafted film, by the way, from Terence Mullock. One reviewer described it as a cathedral of cinema. And that is not an unfair description of that movie. Profoundly beautiful stuff.
[00:37:14] But I got to the end of this very beautiful film and I thought to Myself. Well, why did he call it a hidden life? I couldn't quite make sense of that. I thought I knew what he was getting at, but I couldn't quite make sense of it. Then it becomes explicitly apparent as the credits are rolling and on screen appears a quote from Marianne Evans. And if you know anything about English literature, you'll know that Marianne Evans wrote under a pen name, a pseudonym, and she wrote under the pseudonym George Eliot. So anything by George Eliot is Marianne Evans.
[00:37:41] And in Middlemarch, one of her more well known works, the following quote appears and this is what appeared on screen in the final credits of this movie. The growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been as half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life and rest in unvisited tombs.
[00:38:06] Beautiful and profoundly important sentiment. That's the hidden life, your hidden life of Christian virtue, which is not seen on social media, which doesn't attract high profile followers and is often. Well, it really is consistently the hardest thing you will do. Because I've got to be honest, it's actually easy to get up in front of an audience and to speak, and it's especially when that audience wants to hear from you.
[00:38:36] But it's a lot harder when you have to love your family, to love those people around you you find difficult and there's no audience to perform for.
[00:38:49] You know what I mean? I'm not saying that public speakers should be performing for the audience, but you know what I mean, there's no.
[00:38:54] It's a lot harder when no one else is looking. This is the real test of our integrity. Are we going to truly love when there's nothing in it for us?
[00:39:02] You can't put on a public face and hide it because there's no public leader to see you. So what are you going to do in that moment?
[00:39:09] Are you going to live the hidden life of Christian virtue?
[00:39:12] Are you going to love like Christ calls us to love, and in doing so do the most important thing you can do? There's no acclaim in it.
[00:39:21] It's hard, it keeps happening, but it is precisely. This is the littleness where we meet Christ in the most powerful way.
[00:39:30] If you've read the Gospels, you will know what I'm talking about. If you haven't, or you've only been selectively reading passages, go and read all of the Gospels cover to cover, slowly. Take your time and watch the master in action. Watch Christ and you'll Learn a lot about him. And one of the things you'll quickly discover is that Christ's power is not in power. His power is in his littleness and humility.
[00:39:53] It is the smallness of absolute, total self giving love. Where I become so small, I totally abandon myself in love for God and for neighbour.
[00:40:05] And that's about as small as it gets. But that is, it's powerful and that's what changes the world. And this quote is really true.
[00:40:13] Like things, yeah, they're not in a good space at the moment for the west. But I tell you what, they could be a whole lot worse if there wasn't a whole lot of hidden virtue going on in our culture that was being lived faithfully by people that you don't know the name of, who don't have public profiles, who are not Wes Huff style or size celebrities.
[00:40:29] But man, they are doing the work. And I'm thinking of people right now. I'm thinking, like throughout my own Catholic tradition, we've got so many saints. Saint Therese of Azure, Saint Teresa of Avila, Saint Francis of Assisi, Saint Elizabeth. There's just so many of them, their littleness, where they've just basically allowed God to love them deeply into his holiness, that it's just shone out through their small hidden lives. And. And it's just radically transformative.
[00:40:56] But then there's also people that you don't know the name of. You know, like, you know their names now. These people have been canonized saints. So you, you know, you've heard their names and you might know of their stories. But there are plenty of others too, who you don't know.
[00:41:07] I have even. I'm thinking of right now, some Protestant friends that I know, some people that I've met who are Protestants and are associates or friends and that really are. They are living that beautiful hidden life. You wouldn't know who they were.
[00:41:22] I think of one woman in particular who has a particular health condition and she has to grapple on an ongoing basis with some very serious and meaningful suffering.
[00:41:33] And I know, I see in her writings a genuine grappling with that and a real.
[00:41:39] The beauty of that hidden life. It's powerful.
[00:41:42] Friends of mine are a Protestant couple who adopted child and the situation and the circumstances were challenging and difficult.
[00:41:55] But you're like, you don't know their name and there's no public acclaim for that. And it's not glamorous, but they're just doing it and it's beautiful.
[00:42:04] I was actually in a meeting recently where this particular person was speaking to A proposal that was on the table about a particular initiative, a possible initiative.
[00:42:15] And this person made the statement that even if this particular initiative saves only one human life, then all of it has been worth it.
[00:42:27] And it just cut me to the quick. I was like, I could hear the words of Christ and what this person was saying.
[00:42:34] It's true. It's absolutely true.
[00:42:36] That's the hidden life.
[00:42:40] It's in the smallness that God's power is most profound.
[00:42:45] It's not about earthly power and earthly acclaim. In fact, consistently Christ warns us against those kinds of things.
[00:42:51] But we, in our small mindedness, we think, no, no, no, this initiative's got to save tens of thousands or hundreds or whatever it is, whatever our metric is for success, otherwise it's a failure or it's not worth engaging in.
[00:43:05] That's not how God thinks.
[00:43:07] God literally tells us that if you've read your Gospels, you hear Christ say this, the good shepherd will leave the 99 to go after the 1, the woman who has 10 drachmas and one of them goes missing, she'll turn the whole house upside down looking for that one drachma.
[00:43:28] It's, this is God's smallness, but it's the power. It is the most profound power in the world. Your hidden life is most important and the hidden life is most important.
[00:43:40] And it's very easy to lose sight of that. That hidden life of Christian virtue is the most profound and some of the most profound and loving activism, dare I call it that, for Christianity.
[00:43:51] Some of the most profound life changing stuff is happening in the hidden life.
[00:43:58] And I think the Wes Huff scandal is a reminder to turn back to that truth, to stop being so obsessed. I saw this around Wes himself where once his rise to fame, his meteoric rise to fame, just boom. It hurt like a supernova exploding.
[00:44:15] It was obvious. I could see people attaching themselves to his celebrity. It was alluring, it's seductive.
[00:44:24] And you know, there's an appeal in this. And we start getting fooled into thinking that this is where God is most powerful. This is where the most important work of Christianity is being done. But in actual fact, it's not.
[00:44:39] I saw someone I know commenting online about 24 hours ago about how disheartening it was for them when this type of scandal happens. Because they themselves have pursued the world of Christian scholarship and have got for themselves a degree, including a Ph.D.
[00:44:56] and because of circumstances, they have not been able, like their original plan and thinking was that the scholarship would allow them to actually they'd be ministering out of that scholarship. And unfortunately. Well, should I say unfortunately, but life and God's direction in life has been different. And so they've had to. That scholarship has become for them the thing they've had to park. So they've had to go and do other work, to feed their family and to pay the bills and do all that kind of stuff.
[00:45:25] And I know this person, what this person was saying. I think it's a very valid statement that they were making, how disheartening it is for someone in that situation when someone like Wes Huff does what he's done.
[00:45:37] Whereas people who have done it the honest way often feel like they're sitting on the sidelines. But maybe, just maybe, what we should remember in that moment is that in actual fact, that what that person is doing, who is a scholar, who's not being a scholar, but is loving his wife and his kids and his living this life to the fullness where God is present in the mundane, ordinary stuff, maybe that's actually the most important stuff.
[00:46:02] Maybe that's what we need to remember and to do that the littleness of our lives is where God is often at his most powerful and the most important stuff is happening.
[00:46:16] But to do that, to live that hidden life, while prayer is essential and a recognition and understanding of what prayer is, that prayer is not our work.
[00:46:26] It's certainly not about a feeling, certainly not about our beautiful, eloquent words. Prayer is the work of God in us.
[00:46:35] Prayer is us allowing ourselves to be transformed by God by simply stopping and recognizing that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are present with us there every moment.
[00:46:47] And prayer is us stopping to step into the life of the Trinity and allow God to transform us.
[00:46:54] And what that means is all of a sudden you realize it's not about what I do.
[00:46:58] It's not about a feeling that I get.
[00:47:00] It's about just stepping into that. That space of prayer and letting God and trusting God to do that work and to transform us.
[00:47:08] Because you can't really live the hidden life of virtue again if it's just a series of talking points. And that's been the danger. And those who've heard me speak publicly in recent years will know I've talked about this. My concerns with a sense of Christianity that is reduced just to apologetic talking points or just to answering objections.
[00:47:27] Those answers must come from a lived reality. And that lived reality must be personal holiness.
[00:47:34] Your personal holiness does matter. It's where Christ is sanctifying you. Sanctification is a process that we're all called to go through. The act of justification is not something we choose or we earn. God does that. In the Catholic tradition, it's very clearly spelled out that baptism is the point of justification. But then from that point onwards, the process of sanctification needs to unfold. And sanctification is God working in us and us allowing God to transform us and make us more like the image of His Son, Jesus.
[00:48:11] And that process is something we have to keep saying yes to.
[00:48:15] So we can't. We don't save ourselves, but we do say yes to that. And the moment we stop saying yes to that, we're in trouble. And we can't live that hidden life of virtue.
[00:48:27] And so our personal holiness is essential.
[00:48:30] And it's just fundamental to the mission of the church.
[00:48:35] It's fundamental to the spreading of the gospel. It's fundamental to living that hidden life.
[00:48:41] And it's a profound and beautiful and challenging thing to love more like Christ. But that's the call. That's the fundamental call at the heart of holiness. That's how we set ourselves aside.
[00:48:52] To be holy is to be set aside. It's to love like Christ loves. And it's hard, man.
[00:48:57] Even on the best of days, I find it hard.
[00:49:00] But that's what changes the world. And it's not like if all you've got is snappy apologetic answers.
[00:49:06] And this has been my fear for a while that in many ways, people have seen Christianity as a type of empiricism. And you have the right data points, you present in a culture impressed or, you know, certainly impressed by, but also seduced by and, you know, captured by empiricism as the only way of things, the myth of progress, etc.
[00:49:32] That, you know, we try and reduce Christianity to that as well.
[00:49:36] And we say, oh, it's just about, you know, accepting these empirical data points. And then you'll see.
[00:49:41] But in actual fact, the call is a call to love.
[00:49:48] And the older I get, the more I realize how difficult that is. But I also realize how important, profoundly important that is.
[00:49:56] And I just pray that God would continue to transform me and equip me with every good gift that I need to love like Him.
[00:50:08] And so the only way I can do that is just to surrender my smallness, my littleness, my brokenness to him and to keep focusing on the most important work of all.
[00:50:17] Not the celebrity, not the big following, not even the scandals that happen. There will always be scandals.
[00:50:23] There were scandals right from the very beginning of Christianity.
[00:50:27] Almost all of the disciples abandoned Jesus. One of them has betrayed him, another one is denying him three times.
[00:50:35] The church has always been wracked by scandal, by people who fall away.
[00:50:40] And when you read the Gospels, you realize that Christ never said it was going to be this mass movement of great populism and following.
[00:50:49] There would be the wheat and the weed that would grow up together. There would be many who are called, few who are chosen.
[00:50:58] It's the reality of what this is. It's the narrow hard way.
[00:51:03] But Christ loves all and calls all all. Every single one of us creatures is called to that narrow way.
[00:51:14] And our life of sanctification, allowing God to transform us to be more like a son and grow in holiness, that's the most important work. That's the hidden life. And as I said, I know some really beautiful people who are doing that, Protestant and Catholic, and you don't know their names.
[00:51:33] And that's actually a really good thing.
[00:51:35] Thanks for tuning in. Don't forget, live by goodness, truth and beauty, not by lies. And I'll see you next time on the Dispatches.
[00:51:58] Sa.